Are all hitch mounted carriers created equel ?

[dhmedic24]

I have a Sportrack 4EZ. I love it. Bikes are all secure. No cosmetic damage to any bike that's spent any time on it. I've hauled a 29er, 26er, 24 and 20 at the same time on it with no problem. I think a rack is a personal preference and may depend on several circumstances the buyer must face. A full suspension bike may not work on a hanging type due to the front shock or a hardtail may not work due to top tube slope, i.e. small or extra small frame. Price may inhibit the purchase of a Kuat or 1upUSA rack. Buy the rack that best suits your needs vs. budget vs. style preference.

[Roy]

Your choise of racks could be influenced by your vehicle. If you have pick up with a 2" receiver or a car with a 1.25 receiver.
I favor a rack that bolts into the reciever. (reduces vibration)
If you chose a tray design, look for swing arm front wheel clamp and a quick rear tire clamp. (tire straps wear out fast)
If you have a SUV with a top piviot rear hatch look for opening clearance. (drop down design and/or swing clearence) Pick Up's present a real problem for hitch mounts.
Look for modular design, so you can add on later.
If you transport in ice and snow, look for a corrision resisent materials. ( powder coatings and S.S. fasteners )
Weight and storage space requirments can be big considerations.
If you get a new a car every 2 years (lease) look for brand that sells adaptors for different recievers and geometries.
Long term consider a big brand that will stay in bussiness. (parts, accesories, and updates )

Roy

[Nooge]

For tray racks, Saris Thelma 2 is $290. Yakima stick up is $250. Thule 990xt is $270. All reputable companies.

I don't have experience with these particular ones, but tray racks are the way to go. You can go to REI and play with some of these